How many FR at P5 schools, especially at say top 25 schools actually MAKE an IMPACT. Not many. I think if you look at most years, you will see a lot of 5* recruits with something like 8 points and 3 boards a game, and 4* recruits with half that. You will see the occasional surprises, like we did with SGA, Herro, but those aren't common.
The biggest jump is usually from FR to SOPH year, because 1) players have that year of experience under their belt, and 2) a full summer of workouts to get into better shape, and 3) they are becoming more physically mature